Who decides Obamacare rates?
The Affordable Care Act tries to bring a level of transparency to health insurance rate increases. It doesn't always work out that way though.
Health insurance rate increases
Obamacare rates are also rising, which isn't unexpected.
Health insurance premiums have risen rapidly for more than a decade. Many times, insurance companies have been able to raise rates without explaining their actions to regulators or the public.
• In most cases, consumers received little or no information about proposed premium increases, and weren't told why they were getting large rate increases.
The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) is tasked with issuing regulations and setting up a process for the annual review of unreasonable increases in premium rates by insurance carriers across the country.
♦ The Affordable Care Act requires that large proposed premium increases be evaluated to make sure they're based on reasonable cost assumptions and solid evidence.
• The regulations lay out a process for the states and the federal government to review rate increases by insurers, and to publicly disclose those increases.
• The regulations define the threshold at which a premium increase becomes subject to review, and outline a process for evaluating whether the increase is unreasonable.
• Insurance companies must provide easy-to-understand information to their customers about their reasons for significant rate increases, and must publicly justify and post on their website any unreasonable rate increases.
♦ HHS doesn't have the authority to deny premium increases.
• The hope is that requiring more open disclosure from insurance companies will discourage excessive increases.
The Affordable Care Act made $250 million available to states to take action against insurers seeking unreasonable rate hikes.
This is grant money provided to the states to help them improve their oversight of proposed health insurance rate increases. To date, almost all states have taken advantage of this grant money.
• Generally, the federal provisions don't override state laws and regulations that provide more extensive scrutiny, or the power to reject proposed rate increases.
While many states have passed laws that let them deny unreasonable increases in some insurance markets, a few other states have taken a pro-business approach, and rate increases seldom get challenged until there's a loud public outcry.
What is unreasonable?
HHS encourages states to set up rate review systems, and most have done so.
• In the beginning, the ACA called for rate increases above 10% to be reviewed. This was the rule for many years.
In 2019, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) raised the federal rate review threshold. Now, health insurers must submit justifications and undergo an automatic reasonableness review for proposed rate increases of 15% or more in the individual and small group markets.
By raising the floor to 15%, the administration exempted a large portion of rate hikes from the mandatory federal transparency process.
The outcome: insurers could raise premiums by 11%, 13% or 14.9% without triggering an automatic federal "reasonableness review" or being forced to publish a public explanation for their customers.
If a state lacks the resources or authority to conduct the required rate reviews, HHS conducts them.
• In a few states, HHS conducts the reviews because the state doesn't have an effective rate review program.
The rate review regulations are meant to work together with other parts of the Affordable Care Act to help hold premiums down.
• A little-known part of the law requires insurers to spend at least 80% of premium dollars on direct medical care (85% for large group plans).
• The intent is to improve the quality of care, instead of using premiums to cover overhead, advertising, and executive salaries and bonuses.
• If an insurer fails to meet that test, it must pay a rebate to its enrollees.
♦ In 2019, the Trump administration's changes also let insurers keep more premiums. Insurers could claim that a flat 0.8% of the premium goes toward quality improvement programs.
This essentially took something that would have been an administrative cost and shifted it toward the consumer side of the equation. Insurers became less likely to have to return money to consumers, and were expected to increase their profits.
It's estimated that this rule change let insurers keep $67 million a year rather than return it to enrollees.
♦ In 2022, the Biden administration repealed the 0.8% shortcut and tightened the rules, so insurers can only count spending that actually goes toward improving care.
♦ Want to see your insurer's proposed rate increase? Most states post rate filings online, and the federal government lists them at ratereview.healthcare.gov.
Source: CMS, HHS