Individual Mandate

4
min read
A- A+
read

Individual Mandate

0 comments

Requirement to have health coverage or pay a penalty.

Individual Mandate

The individual mandate was probably the most vilified part of the Affordable Care Act (ACA).

The goal of the mandate was to push people to keep health coverage.

Mandate is gone, or maybe not

January 1, 2019 — The federal mandate is no longer in effect.

♦ States can have their own mandate.

Several states have adopted their own mandates, some with tax penalties. These include:

  • California - with penalty
  • District of Columbia - with penalty
  • Massachusetts - with penalty
  • New Jersey - with penalty
  • Rhode Island - with penalty
  • Vermont - no penalty

Vermont has a mandate but hasn't imposed a tax penalty for not having coverage. Other states have considered individual mandates, but none have passed one recently.

Maryland asks about health insurance coverage on state tax returns, but so far only to encourage people to enroll.

♦ The ACA mandate required everyone who could afford it to buy health insurance providing at least a minimal level of healthcare coverage. Failing to buy insurance could mean paying a penalty.

The ACA mandate was meant to help stabilize the market, and to encourage people to avoid skimpy products that provide little coverage and leave them at financial risk. Individual states are now left to find their own way.

The ACA mandate has two parts

The Affordable Care Act, commonly called Obamacare, requires (mandates) everyone to have health insurance.

• Part 1 — The responsibility to have health insurance. This is referred to as the shared responsibility mandate.

• Part 2 — The responsibility to pay a tax penalty if you don't have health insurance or a valid reason for not buying it. This is called the individual shared responsibility payment.

At the end of 2017, President Trump signed a bill that repealed the tax penalty.

• The bill didn't eliminate the part of the law that actually says everyone is required to have health insurance (Part 1).

• This means that even though the mandate is technically still in place, there's no longer a penalty for not complying.

• This point was the foundation of a lawsuit filed in February 2018 by 18 GOP attorneys general and 2 GOP governors to invalidate the entire law.

• On June 17, 2021, the Supreme Court, on a 7-to-2 vote, turned aside the latest effort by Republicans to kill the healthcare law.

Not everyone is required

Some groups that are exempt from this requirement include:

• Members of recognized religious sects or divisions

• Members of healthcare sharing ministries

• Individuals not lawfully present in the U.S.

• Incarcerated individuals

Mandate free?

A handful of states have adopted their own individual mandates to replace the federal one.

State mandates were modeled on the Affordable Care Act. They offer exemptions too, but states can customize them.

• Massachusetts had a mandate in place before the ACA. The District of Columbia and New Jersey scrambled to put one together to start in 2019. California and Rhode Island followed in 2020.

• Vermont passed legislation for a mandate to take effect in 2020, but hasn't decided on a tax penalty.

• Maryland considered an individual mandate, but lawmakers decided for now to see if a voluntary approach would work.

• Hawaii and Connecticut considered a mandate in 2018, but nothing passed. The subject appears shelved for the time being.

♦ That's why the ACA's requirements and exemptions are explained below, for reference and a bit of history.

Historical Information

Affordable Care Act - Mandate

January 1, 2019 — The federal mandate is no longer in effect.

Requirements

Individuals were required to maintain Minimum Essential Coverage (MEC) for themselves and their dependents to avoid the individual mandate penalty. As the name implies, it's coverage that provides a minimal level of benefits.

An individual with only Minimum Essential Coverage runs a great risk of high healthcare expenses. Still, MEC plans are considered better than no insurance at all.

Read more about what qualifies as Minimum Essential Coverage.

Exemptions

Exemptions are available based on a number of circumstances, including certain hardships, some life events, health coverage or financial status, and membership in some groups.

You claimed most coverage exemptions on your federal tax return. Some required you to fill out and mail an application to the Marketplace.

Hardships are life situations that keep you from getting health insurance. To learn more about hardship exemptions and what qualifies, visit Hardship Exemptions.

♦ Even though the mandate's penalty has been zeroed out, hardship exemptions still exist.

Anyone 30 or older who wants to buy a catastrophic plan still needs a hardship exemption. But starting in 2026, people who don't qualify for premium tax credits or cost-sharing reductions get one automatically. See Catastrophic Health Plans.

Sometimes people have gaps in their health insurance, like when they change jobs. The law allowed certain Coverage Exemptions so people didn't have to pay a penalty.

I am not a U.S. citizen

All residents of the U.S., including non-citizens, were required to have health insurance unless they qualified for an exemption.

In general, anyone "lawfully present" in the U.S. had to have at least Minimum Essential Coverage. This included green card holders, refugees and people granted asylum.

I am a U.S. citizen but living abroad?

All U.S. citizens were subject to the mandate.

However, if you weren't physically present in the United States for at least 330 full days, or were a resident of a foreign country for an entire tax year, you were considered to have Minimum Essential Coverage for that year.

You needed to report this when you filed federal taxes.

What if I am over 65?

If you're over 65 and qualify for Medicare, you need to enroll in Medicare rather than a Marketplace plan, unless you have insurance through work or retiree health benefits.

Medicare is not part of the Marketplaces.

If you didn't qualify for Medicare or have other coverage, you had to buy Minimum Essential Coverage or pay a penalty. Visit the Marketplace for your state to see if you're eligible for a premium tax credit to help pay for coverage.

Medicare consists of two primary parts

♦ Part A (Hospital Insurance)

♦ Part B (Medical Insurance)

If you have Part A, you're considered covered under the healthcare law and don't need a Marketplace plan.

♦ Having only Medicare Part B (Medical Insurance) doesn't meet this requirement.

Short coverage gap

You paid a penalty only for the months you didn't have coverage. Coverage for even one day in a month counted that month as covered, and there was no penalty for that month.

Short gaps in coverage were allowed without a penalty. This was called a short coverage gap exemption.

The short coverage gap exemption was limited to no more than two consecutive months. If you went three consecutive months without coverage, then none of those months were treated as a short coverage gap.

For two months to qualify as a short coverage gap, you had to have coverage at some point during the third month, even if for one day.

♦ If you had more than one short coverage gap during the year, you were exempt only for the month(s) in the first gap.

This is a confusing subject, for sure. Learn more ... Coverage Exemptions

What is the penalty?

If you could afford health insurance but chose not to buy it, you had to pay a fee, or penalty, as it's sometimes called.

The IRS calls the penalty a Shared Responsibility Payment.

The penalty increased each year it was in effect, and it could be quite costly not to buy health insurance.

See how the penalty is calculated ...

♦ Congress eliminated the federal penalty starting in 2019. The last year with a federal penalty was 2018. Some states still charge their own penalty. See Penalty.

Add new comment