Medical Care Wrongly Denied
Advantage plans wrongly deny medical services for many older Americans every year.
Nothing new actually
Medicare Advantage is not as good as it's cracked up to be.
♦ A study by the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC), a nonpartisan agency of Congress, found that it could not conclude Medicare Advantage plans "systematically provide better quality" than regular Medicare.
The report goes on to explain that Medicare pays these plans more than it would spend if enrollees were in regular, fee-for-service Medicare. In its March 2026 report, MedPAC estimated the difference at 14%, or about $76 billion, in 2026. Everyone on Medicare helps pay for it: MedPAC says it raises Part B premiums by about $175 a year per person.
The insurance industry disputes MedPAC's math, arguing it overstates how much plans gain by coding patients as sicker.
• Other studies have found that plans do what they can to keep this money by too often denying claims.
♦ A 2022 study by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Office of Inspector General (OIG) points a finger at Medicare Advantage plans.
• The study found an alarming number of cases where Medicare Advantage plans denied coverage for medical services that would have been covered under original Medicare.
Federal investigators reviewed a week's worth of requests in 2019 and found that around 13% of denials in Medicare Advantage plans would have been allowed under original Medicare.
• Based on that small sample, the investigators estimated that 85,000 requests were likely wrongly denied in 2019.
The study also found that nearly one-fifth of the time, Medicare Advantage plans denied payment requests that met Medicare coverage rules and should have been approved.
• That translates to an estimated 1.5 million refused payments for all of 2019, delaying or blocking payments for services providers had already delivered.
Most of the payment denials OIG found were the result of human error during manual claims processing and system errors, according to the report.
♦ The report said many of the prior authorization denials came from Medicare Advantage plans applying their own clinical criteria that are not required by Medicare.
The report details examples of Medicare Advantage plans that used specific, mandatory requirements that led to denials of prior authorization requests for medically necessary services.
One example in the report tells of a Medicare Advantage plan that refused to approve a follow-up MRI to find out whether an adrenal lesion was cancerous, because the lesion was supposedly too small. Medicare's rules don't restrict follow-up MRIs based on the size of a lesion. On appeal, the plan agreed to pay.
Prior authorization denials of requests that meet coverage rules can do real harm to Medicare Advantage beneficiaries, the report noted.
♦ "These denials can delay or prevent beneficiary access to medically necessary care; lead beneficiaries to pay out of pocket for services that are covered by Medicare; or create an administrative burden for beneficiaries or their providers who choose to appeal the denial."
As of 2026, about 35 million people, or 55% of eligible Medicare beneficiaries, are enrolled in Medicare Advantage plans. That's already more than half, years ahead of earlier projections.
♦ Unlike original Medicare, where the federal government is the insurer, Medicare Advantage plans are run by private insurance companies.
The government pays the insurers who sell these plans a fixed monthly fee to provide services to each Medicare beneficiary.
The report points out what we've all known for some time: "There is the potential incentive for insurers to deny access to services and payments in an attempt to increase profits."
• Medicare Advantage plans often look attractive because they offer the same basic coverage as original Medicare at a seemingly lower cost, plus extra benefits like vision and dental care that traditional Medicare doesn't offer.
Medicare Advantage plans can offer some extra benefits because the federal government pays them more.
The report actually mentions this as one of Medicare Advantage's downsides. It pointed out that people enrolled in Medicare Advantage plans may not be aware there may be greater barriers to getting certain types of health care services compared to original Medicare.
• Medicare Advantage plans' most disagreeable cost-cutting strategy is prior authorization.
This is a common requirement that doctors and other medical providers get the plan's approval before a beneficiary can receive certain medical services. If the plan disagrees that a procedure is medically necessary, the plan may refuse to pay for it.
The beneficiary is then left paying all the costs out of pocket, or delaying the service while an appeal plays out.
The good news: most people who appeal win. In 2024, more than 8 in 10 appeals overturned the plan's denial. See our Medicare Advantage Appeals Process page.
What will be done?
The inspector general called on the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), which oversees Medicare, to more tightly regulate these plans to make sure they follow Medicare's rules for what should be covered.
CMS agreed with the findings.
♦ Some real changes have come, though critics say they don't go far enough. Since 2024, CMS has required plans to follow traditional Medicare's coverage rules instead of inventing their own. And since 2026, plans must decide prior authorization requests faster, within 72 hours for urgent requests and 7 days for standard ones, and explain their denials. Whether plans actually follow the rules is another matter.
• In June 2025, major insurers also promised to streamline and reduce prior authorization. It's a voluntary promise, so watch whether they follow through.
The American Medical Association (AMA) continues to push for reform of the prior authorization process.
There's a bill called the "Improving Seniors' Timely Access to Care Act" (H.R. 3514 / S. 1816) that would require Medicare Advantage plans to streamline and standardize prior authorization and be more open about their requirements.
It's one of the most popular bills in Congress, with nearly 300 House cosponsors and more than 70 in the Senate. A version passed the House unanimously back in 2022 but stalled. In July 2026, it cleared a key House committee 45-0. It still needs a full House vote and Senate approval.
♦ The Biden administration issued a rule change in May 2022 that strengthens Medicare Advantage network adequacy. The rule took effect for 2023 plans.
Network adequacy refers to a health plan's ability to deliver the benefits it promised, by providing reasonable access to enough in-network primary care and specialty doctors, as well as all the health care services in the contract.
Under the rule, CMS will approve an application for a new or expanded Medicare Advantage contract only after the insurer shows it has enough contracted doctors to care for enrollees.
That might be good. Because right now too many people sign up for lower-cost Advantage plans, only to find out they have a very limited choice of specialists.