What makes a great doctor?
A good doctor treats a disease while a great doctor treats the patient.
What does it take to be a great doctor?
A great doctor is more than someone who attended a famous school or is associated with a respected hospital. A great doctor is special.
Being a great doctor is more than learning a skill or specialty. A great doctor knows how and when to use that knowledge.
A great doctor is someone you never hesitate to introduce to your friends.
Traits of a Great Doctor
Doctors tend to look at themselves differently than their patients do. Doctors speak of fellow doctors who are effective at treating an ailment as good or even great doctors. They like to emphasize that doctors need to be knowledgeable and confident. These are good traits, but they're not what the average person sees as most important.
A great doctor has traits that can be condensed into four groups:
• Listens & Cares
• Understands & Respects
• Explains & Teaches
• Trust & Experience
Listens & Cares
• A great doctor makes the effort to show they have time for you. A great doctor takes the time to sit down and listen to you. They're interested in you as a person, not just as a patient. They try to find out what bothers you most and what you hope they can do for you. A great doctor gets the whole story before deciding the path to take.
• A great doctor looks you in the eye, not at the computer screen. They're not distracted by noises. They focus on you and don't let their staff interrupt their time with you. A great doctor asks questions and encourages you to speak freely. A great doctor genuinely cares for their patients and shows it.
Understands & Respects
• A great doctor shows they understand and respect your situation. They know it can be difficult and at times frightening when we experience sudden, unknown changes in our health. We rely on our doctor to bring calm and peace back into our lives.
• A great doctor considers the whole person. If you're being treated for a condition that requires assistance, they'll try to understand your home environment. Do you have someone to drive you or help with daily tasks?
• A great doctor is more interested in getting you off medications than on them. When they have to prescribe an expensive medicine, they'll try to find out if you can afford it. There's no point in prescribing something you can't buy.
• A great doctor shows respect. They respect your time as much as you respect theirs. They don't leave you sitting and waiting forever, only to pop in and give you 15 seconds to explain why you came.
• A great doctor respects your privacy and won't discuss important information in an open setting. They always take care to make sure you're dressed and not put in an embarrassing situation.
Explains & Teaches
• A great doctor speaks loudly and clearly, using words you understand. They explain the treatment plan. They do more than just hand you a printout and tell you to read it. They talk with you and confirm you understand and can actually follow the plan.
• A great doctor isn't bothered if you ask how your life might be affected by the treatment. They want you to understand as much as you can about your condition and what to expect. They want you to be informed, so the two of you can best manage your treatment together.
• A great doctor makes themselves available in case something goes wrong. When you start a new treatment plan, you want someone you can depend on to tell you what to do if the treatment makes you sick. No one wants to hear an answering machine say, "Any message left after 3 pm, we will get back to you the next day."
Trust & Experience
"To be a doctor … means much more than to dispense pills or to patch up or repair torn flesh and shattered minds. To be a doctor is to be an intermediary between man and God," wrote Felix Martí-Ibáñez in To Be a Doctor.
Dr. Martí-Ibáñez wrote these words as encouragement. Unfortunately, many doctors think they earned this position along with their degree. Such a high pedestal requires a lot of trust. Something most people don't give freely. But something that can be earned.
• Many doctors believe they can be great if they attend the most famous school and master the fundamentals. A fantastic education doesn't equal a great doctor. Where the doctor trained doesn't always reflect their ability or their personality.
• Most people assume doctors are competent, even if they have no experience with the doctor. But most people don't trust their doctor 100% the first time they meet. Trust builds over time.
• Many doctors believe documenting their patient's illness and understanding blood results is enough to treat their patient effectively and be a wonderful doctor. This is far from the truth, and patients know it.
Some doctors order more tests than they need to. Relying heavily on tests doesn't build trust, and it can cost you a lot of money.
♦ What people do understand is a hands-on examination. Hands-on exams build trust and help create a more patient-centered experience. A careful physical exam can catch things tests miss.
Trust is about knowing your doctor puts your interests ahead of anything else. Trust really gets mangled up when we learn the doctor has a financial interest in the treatment plan or the treatment facility.
♦ Want to know if your doctor gets money from drug or device companies? Search their name on Open Payments, a free federal database. It lists speaking fees, consulting, meals and travel paid to doctors. A payment doesn't mean your doctor is doing anything wrong, but it's good to know.
♦ Experience is important, but it's difficult to measure. We tend to trust older doctors more than younger doctors, because we believe they've had more experience.
Interestingly, a large 2017 study found hospital patients of younger doctors did slightly better than those of older doctors, possibly because younger doctors trained on the latest guidelines. Experience matters most when it's experience with your condition.
Your doctor's experience will play a critical role in your health care. Don't be afraid to ask your doctor how much experience they have with your condition. A great doctor won't hesitate to explain how people they treated in a similar situation fared.
♦ The Affordable Care Act called for a public website with information on doctor quality. Today that information is on Medicare's Care Compare website, under "Doctors & clinicians."
• Search by your location and your doctor's name. Most doctors who accept Medicare are listed, and some show quality ratings or patient survey scores. Many don't have any scores at all.
It's worth checking, but don't weigh it too heavily. There's still a lot of work to be done.
♦ While you're online searching physician data, it wouldn't hurt to see how your local hospital is rated. CMS has much more information on hospitals because of stronger reporting rules.
Don't forget to check how well hospitals handle infection control. It's a very dangerous, growing problem, and you don't want the hospital to make you sick. See Choosing a Good Hospital.
The opposite of a great doctor
Poor Doctor
Unless you're rather young, you've met a poor doctor once or twice in your life. Seldom do people return to these doctors. Here are some of the more common complaints about them:
• Overly confident to the point of being disrespectful
• Terrible bedside manner
• Doesn't care about me
• Cold and callous when asking questions and giving instructions
• Doesn't explain so I can understand
• Doesn't take the time to listen
• Uncaring and not understanding of my situation
• Hurried and not thorough in evaluation
• Makes me feel like I'm a bother
• Ignores me, takes phone calls or sends emails while I wait
• No clear plan, no clear explanation of the expected outcome
• Always have to sit and wait
• Never keeps the appointment time
• Charges a lot… For what?
• Won't refill a prescription without another office visit
• Too many tests and no conclusion
• Quickly pushes me off to a specialist
• Many billing mistakes
• Office staff is rude
It's sad that these doctors affect so many people. But it's even sadder that some people feel compelled to keep seeing them. You should never be patient with such doctors.
Changing doctors is nothing to be afraid of. Your health takes priority.
There are many very good doctors who would be happy to welcome you. You may even find a great one.
For help finding one, see Choosing a Primary Care Doctor.